On Restrictive and Non-restrictive Relative Clauses in Mandarin Chinese
Vol. 33 No. 1 6/2003
Title |
On Restrictive and Non-restrictive Relative Clauses in Mandarin Chinese |
Author |
Jo-wang Lin |
Genre |
Article |
Pages |
199-240 |
Download |
|
Language |
English |
Key words |
Relative Clauses, Restrictive, Non-restrictive |
Abstrac |
Whether or not Chinese has non-restrictive relative clauses has been very controversial. This paper reviews existing arguments for and against treating pre-determiner or post-determiner relatives as non-rest rictive relatives in the literature. I show that arguments for analyzing pre-determiners or post-determiner relatives as non- restrictive relatives are not convincing. All relative clauses that occur with a determiner should be analyzed as restrictive. However, it is too strong a claim to say that non- restrictive relative clauses do not exist in Chinese. When the antecedent of a relative clause is a proper name, the non-restrictive interpretation is allowed if the relative clause describes a more or less permanent or stable property. |